Blog

Red meat: Not so bad after all?

A lot of people I know have cut back on meat–specifically red meat–in an effort to make their diets healthier.  I think there are lots of good reasons to eat less meat. But regular readers of this blog will know that I’ve long been suspicious of this idea that “red” meat is any worse for you than “white” meat.

See also: Meat and mortality: What’s color got to do with it?

This idea that red meat is unhealthy is self-reinforcing. Because we’ve all convinced ourselves that this is true, studies which find a link between red meat and some sort of disease are much more likely to be published and get a lot more press than studies which find no such link.  Never mind that what we categorize as “red” and “white” makes absolutely no sense, either nutritionally or zoologically.

So I consider it my duty to point out that a recent meta-analysis published in the Nutrition Journal found no association between eating red meat and risk of prostate cancer.  And while I’m at it, I’ll remind you that a widely-cited report linking red meat and cancer risk was later found to contain significant errors and omissions. The authors later acknowledged that they had overstated the risks. Of course, the retraction got way less press than the error.

A more rational approach

If you want to make your diet healthier, I suggest a color-blind approach to meat. Don’t worry about whether it came from a cow or a chicken. Instead:

  • choose meat that is raised on healthy feed and without hormones or antibiotics
  • right-size portions: a 3 ounce serving is the size of a deck of cards
  • avoid fried or charred meats (See also: Tips for healthier cookouts)
  • avoid processed meats with added salt and/or nitrates
  • add lots of vegetables

Your thoughts?

Do water filters remove valuable minerals?

Q. In your podcast on mineral water, you said that tap water can be a source of minerals such as calcium and magnesium.  If I use a water filtration pitcher to filter my tap water, am I removing these nutrients?

A. Great question!  To answer it, I got in touch with both PUR and Brita, who manufacture water filtration pitchers. Both assured me that any calcium or magnesium that is in your tap water to start with will not be removed by the filtration process.

Trying to eat more veggies? Don’t forget about sea vegetables!

Trying to get more vegetables into your diet but getting bored with broccoli and spinach? There’s a whole category of super-nutritious vegetables you may be overlooking. Sea vegetables, otherwise known as seaweed, are a great way to add variety to your five-a-day routine. You can add sea vegetables to soups or stir-fries or make a seaweed salad instead of the same old tossed salad. You can even use seaweed to make nutritious—and addictive—chips to snack on.

This article is also available as a podcast. Click to listen

What Kinds of Seaweed are Good to Eat?

As with land vegetables, there are lots of different kinds of sea vegetables, with various flavors and textures. Some are soft, others are chewy; some are mild, others very briny.  Here’s a brief guide to some common sea vegetables.

What Are the Different Types of Sea Vegetables?

Alaria is harvested in the Atlantic and is a distant cousin of Japanese wakame. It has a fairly pronounced briney flavor and a chewy, slightly rubbery texture.

Arame is a delicately textured plant that grows wild off the coast of Japan. It has a soft texture and bland flavor that reminds me of very thin cooked buckwheat noodles.

Dulce, with its broad, reddish-brown fronds, is harvested off the Atlantic coast of Maine. It has a medium strong, somewhat smoky flavor.

Hijiki is a dark, small-leaved seaweed from Japan that resembles dried tobacco. It has a tender-crisp texture and a very mild, almost sweet flavor.

Kombu, or kelp, is a broad-leafed variety that grows wild in the very northernmost region of Japan’s Arctic sea. It’s often used in stocks or ground as a flavor enhancer.

Wakame is a tender, dark-green seaweed that is harvested in Japan. It has a mild flavor and a texture similar to cooked spinach.

What are the Nutritional Benefits of Seaweed?

The nutritional profile of different types of seaweed varies as well. In general, sea vegetables are low in calories and contain a variety of minerals including calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Dulce and alaria, are quite high in iron and vitamin B12, which makes them particularly good choices for vegans who may otherwise have difficulty getting these nutrients.

Some—but not all—types of seaweed are high in sodium. For example, alaria and wakame are both high in sodium, but arame and hijiki are quite low.

Can You Get Too Much Iodine from Seaweed?

Most types of seaweed also contain iodine, a nutrient that’s important for healthy thyroid and neurological function.  Iodized salt is the primary source of iodine in American diets. If you use a natural sea salt instead of iodized salt, including seaweed in your diet can be a good way to be sure you’re getting enough of this important nutrient. But more is not always better. Although iodine is needed for healthy thyroid function, too much iodine can also interfere with your thyroid.

A serving or two per day of seaweed won’t cause a problem for most people. But just to be on the safe side, I suggest avoid eating large amounts of seaweed every single day, particularly kombu or hijiki, which are particularly high in iodine. Dried kelp granules, which are often sold as a salt substitute, are also a potent source of iodine. A quarter teaspoon can provide two or three times the suggested upper limit for iodine intake, so you don’t want to overdo that either.

Where Can You Buy Seaweed?

Dehydrated seaweed is the easiest to find. You may find one or two types in the international aisle of your local grocery store. You’ll probably find a larger selection at a health food store or a natural foods grocer. The best prices and selection are usually found at Asian groceries or markets, where they might even have fresh or frozen seaweed, which is otherwise fairly hard to find. If you’re having trouble finding a good selection, you can also shop online from the sources listed below in the Resources section. Keep a few packages of dried seaweed on hand for those times when you run out of fresh vegetables and don’t have time to make it to the market.

How Do You Prepare Seaweed?

Many dehydrated sea vegetables are ready to use in salads, soups, or stir-fries after a brief soak in cool water; others need to be boiled for a few minutes. Soaking seaweed in water is also a way to reduce the sodium content, although you may end up losing some of the other minerals as well.

Some varieties don’t even need to be rehydrated. For example, dehydrated dulce can be eaten right out of the bag—it tastes sort of like jerky. Or, sauté pieces of dulce in a bit of olive oil until they’re crisp. You can eat it instead of chips, use it in place of the bacon in a BLT, or crumble it over a baked potato.

This article was originally published on QuickandDirtyTips.com

Evidence against BPA is stacking up

As consumers have grown increasingly worried about the potential harm from BPA in plastic water bottles and canned food, food manufacturers have mounted a massive campaign aimed at convincing us that we’re over-reacting. See for example this article from the industry-funded International Food and Information Council: Science and the BPA Controversy

But it’s getting harder and harder to claim that consumers have nothing to fear from “normal” BPA exposure. New data out of Italy links BPA from foods to changes in testosterone levels. These are not lab rats being given huge doses of BPA. These are humans, simply going about their normal lives and eating their usual diet. Continue reading “Evidence against BPA is stacking up” >

How much sunshine do you need to get your Vitamin D?

 

UPDATE: September 2024: There are now a couple of smart-phone apps that are MUCH easier to use than the cool but somewhat clumsy calculator described in my original post!! 

DMinder (iOS/Android)

Vitamin D and UV Tracker (Android)

SunDay Vitamin D and UV Tracker (iOS)

There’s been a lot of hand-wringing lately about people not getting enough vitamin D.  Deficiency is quite common–especially among kids, the elderly, and those with dark skin. And a growing list of diseases and conditions are being linked with vitamin D deficiency. (See also Your Brain on Vitamin D)

Exposure to the sun, without sunscreen, causes your skin to produce vitamin D naturally.

How much sun does it take to satisfy your vitamin D requirements?

If you’ve read anything about this, you’ve probably seen some vague guidelines, recommending “a few minutes every day.” But these recommendations are far too general to be useful. The amount of sun you need to meet your vitamin D requirements varies hugely depending on your location, your skin type, the time of year, the time of day, and even the atmospheric conditions.

A Cool Tool: The vitamin D/UV calculator

Scientists at the Norwegian Institute for Air Research have devised a calculator that will take all those factors into consideration and estimate how many minutes of exposure you need for your skin to produce 25 mcg (the equivalent of 1,000 International Units) of vitamin D.

It’s a very cool tool and the best I’ve seen so far. Be forewarned: It’s not the most user-friendly interface and its very easy to enter the wrong information, which makes your results misleading. But once you get past the technicalities, it’s very interesting to see how much the answers change when you vary the input.

Here are some tips to help you get good results

1. Unless you live in one of a few European or African cities listed as options, you’ll need to determine your latitude and longitude.  A GPS device will tell you your lat/long. You can also find this information here.  VERY IMPORTANT: The program reads all latitudes as N and all longitudes as E. If your latitude is 39 S, enter -39.  If your longitude is 76 W, enter -76. (It took me forever to figure out this quirk!) Also, be sure to click the radio button next to your latitude and longitude entries. It is not automatically selected when you fill in these values.

2. You also need to estimate your complexion, and the options include both “blond” and “pale,” which is a little confusing. (Maybe it makes more sense to Norwegians.) Basically, the six categories are arranged from lightest (pale) to darkest (black).  Make your best guess based on that. I have dark eyes and hair so I chose “darker caucasian.”

3. Enter the time of day you are going out in the sun, expressed as UTC (aka Greenwich Mean Time).  Here is a converter that will convert local time into UTC. The calculator uses a 24 hour clock, so hours from 1pm to midnight are expressed as 13 to 24.  There is also an option that lets you choose “about midday.”  If you enter an actual time, be sure to click the radio button next to your start time. It doesn’t move automatically when you fill in these values.

4. Next, enter how much cloud cover there is.  If you choose “overcast,” you can also enter in the UV Index from your local newspaper’s weather page and the program will estimate the thickness of the cloud deck. Again, be sure to click the radio button if you choose this option. (Disclaimer: I played around with this and couldn’t see that changing the UV index had any effect…)

5. You’re almost done! Next, the calculator wants to know the thickness of the ozone layer. I have to admit, I was unable to find a simple resource to help with this one.  Unless you live under the ozone hole or have some other way of knowing that the ozone is particularly thick or thin where you are, I suggest just setting this one to medium.

6. Find your altitude. Some GPS devices can tell you your altitude, as can Google Earth or topographical maps. But the easiest way may be to simply google “altitude of [your town]”. Remember to convert it to kilometers.  One kilometer = about 3300 feet.

7. Choose your surface.

Here’s what my form looks like all filled in:

UVcalc.jpg

When I submit it for calculation, I learn that here in Baltimore, on a cloudless July day at noon, I need to spend just 5 minutes with my face, hands, and arms exposed to produce 25 mcg (1,000 IU) of vitamin D.  If it were November, I’d need to stay out about half an hour. If it were November, and I were black, it would take an hour and a half. You get the idea.  For most of the year, “a few minutes” of sun would not be enough for me to make enough vitamin D.

Keep in mind that these exposure times are considered enough to maintain healthy vitamin D status. if you are starting out with a vitamin D deficiency, you might need more.

One last thought: Unprotected sun exposure also increases the risk of skin cancer and premature aging of the skin. After you’ve gotten your daily “dose,” I recommend applying a good sunscreen!

Your Brain on Vitamin D

brain.jpgOur collective crush on Vitamin D shows no sign of tapering off.  Researchers just published new results from a 6-year study showing that seniors with low vitamin D levels are 60% more likely to suffer from substantial cognitive decline than those with adequate levels of the nutrients, raising “important new possibilities for treatment and prevention.” (Archives of Internal Medicine.)

Vitamin D supplementation is presumably what they’re talking about. (Is there anyone left out there that’s NOT taking vitamin D?)

But brain aging seems to be a very difficult nut to crack.  One by one, other “important new possibilities for treatment and prevention” of cognitive decline have failed to pan out:  Fish oil, crossword puzzles, exercise, ginkgo biloba…despite high hopes, none turned out to make a significant difference.

Will vitamin D be the breakthrough we’ve all been hoping for?

Could raising low blood levels with supplements do the trick or is there something about the lifestyle of people with higher vitamin D levels that’s helping them stay healthier? Maybe higher vitamin D levels indicate that they spend more time outdoors; perhaps it’s a marker for people who are more active? Or simply healthier?

We’re all so enamored of vitamin D right now, it’s hard to be objective. But, as Tim Byers points out in an editorial for the American Journal of Epidemiology, we’ve been similarly enthralled (and ultimately disillusioned) with other nutrients in the past.  (Anticancer Vitamins du Jour–The ABCED’s So Far.)

I don’t mean to be a Debbie Downer. For all of our sakes, I hope that vitamin D turns out to be the superstar that we hope it is. But, I wouldn’t be surprised if we’re ultimately led back to the same conclusion: There’s just no way to put a healthy lifestyle, diet, and environment (plus good genes) into a pill.

Better results with whole grain baking

Substituting whole wheat flour for white flour in baked goods such as quick breads, muffins, or pancakes can make these treats more nutritious. But unless the recipes have been specifically developed for whole wheat flour, the substitution can also turn your goodies into leaden lumps.

In muffins and other treats made with baking powder or soda, you’ll get better results with whole wheat pastry flour. This whole grain flour is nutritionally similar to traditional whole wheat, but produces lighter and more tender baked goods. Another good option is the confusingly named white whole wheat flour. This is a whole-grain flour made from a “white” variety of wheat. It produces whole grain baked goods that are almost as light in texture as those made with refined white flour.

You’ll find both in stores with a large selection of “natural” or alternative flours, or online.

This article was originally published on QuickandDirtyTips.com

 

Nutritional medicine is (finally) focusing on food

[Archival: Originally published on my (discontinued) NutritionData.com blog]

As we head into the second day of the Nutrition and Health Conference, I can’t help but reflect what a difference a decade makes.

Ten years ago, conferences like this one were dominated by research and presentations about individual nutrients, like tocotrienols or pycnogenol.  The protocols all involved cocktails of high dose nutritional supplements.  The exhibit hall was filled with supplement manufacturers.

This week, I haven’t heard a single presentation (and seen only a handful of slides) about isolated nutrients. Instead, the focus is on food. The research and protocols all address what foods make up the diet, how they are prepared, processed, combined, and balanced to promote health.  And out in the exhibition hall? Vital Choice Wild Seafood, POM pomegranate juice, Pistachio Health.com, and the Washington Red Raspberry commission.

What’s more, we’re finally looking at the big picture rather than individual “super foods.” The title of a talk I’m headed to right now says it all: “Preventing Cancer with Food: Magic Bullets vs. Dietary Patterns.” (presented by Marjorie McCullough from Emory University.)

Finally, nutritional medicine is about food.