Nutrition Trap #2: Quality vs. Quantity

In the first installment of this three-part series, I talked about the all-important difference between natural and healthy.  People often make the mistake of thinking that something is good for you just because it’s all-natural or organic.  Today, I want to explore a different kind of nutritional blind-spot that has to do with quality versus quantity. Even when a food is good for you, it doesn’t necessarily follow that you can eat it in unlimited quantities.  Whole grains and fresh fruits are two examples of healthy foods that can easily be over-consumed.

This article is also available as a podcast. Click to listen:

Hold the Line on Whole Grains

You hear an awful lot these days about the benefits of whole grains.  People who replace refined grain products like white bread with whole grain products like whole wheat bread have lower rates of heart disease, cancer, diabetes, obesity, and many other diseases.  But a lot of people have misunderstood this to mean that whole grains are like vegetables—the more, the better!

I have friends, for example, who wouldn’t be caught dead eating a forkful of white rice—after all, they’re watching their waistlines!  Yet they see nothing wrong with eating two or three cups of brown rice with dinner—and can’t imagine why they struggle with their weight.

Whole grains are definitely better for you than refined grains. But that doesn’t mean that portion sizes don’t matter. Despite being higher in fiber and certain nutrients, whole-grain foods are primarily starch. They provide a lot of calories and relatively little nutritional value. And although whole-grain foods are a little easier on your blood sugar than refined grain foods, they still have a moderate to high glycemic impact.

When it comes to grains, you need to pay attention to quality and quantity.  In fact, when it comes right down to it, quantity may even be more important.  I’d actually rather see you have an appropriately-sized serving of white pasta than an over-sized serving of whole grain pasta. Best of all, of course, would be an appropriately-sized serving of whole grain pasta.

Fruit: How Sweet It Is!

Fruit also has a place in a healthy diet—but, again, more is not necessarily better. Fruits and vegetables both provide important antioxidants, phytonutrients, fiber, fluids—nutrients that protect and enhance your health. However, compared with vegetables, fruits tend to be significantly higher in sugar and calories.

I think people often rationalize that the sugar or calories in fruit doesn’t really “count” because it’s coming from a healthy source. After all, fruit is a food we’re supposed to be eating, right?  And when we talk about limited your added sugar, you don’t have to include fruit in that total. But that’s not a license to eat a pound of raisins at your desk every afternoon.

Fruit is both yummy and good for you. And you’re much better off satisfying your sweet tooth with a piece of fruit than a candy bar. But to keep your diet balanced and your sugar intake within bounds, I suggest limiting fruit to two to four servings a day—and no more than one of those should be in the form of juice.

In the next and final installment in this special three-part series, I’ll have one more tip on how to avoid the biggest nutritional traps.

This article was originally published at QuickandDirtyTips.com

Balancing a High Sodium Diet

Foods high in potassium can help to balance sodium intake.

Q.  I’m a college student and I try to eat healthy. But with the amount of processed foods in the school cafeteria, it’s almost impossible to avoid eating a lot of sodium.  I’m healthy and active with a normal blood pressure and I’ve always considered sodium the least worrisome of the food evils (though high blood pressure does run in my family). I assume that as long as I increase my water intake along with sodium, everything will “balance out” in the body.  Is there any truth to this? If so, how much water is necessary to offset 2400 mg sodium over the recommended daily value?

A. First, I congratulate you for making nutrition a priority!  Secondly, I sympathize with your challenge of limiting sodium when faced with typical cafeteria food. Thirdly, I agree that because you are healthy, active, and have normal blood pressure, you may not need to worry too much about some extra sodium in your diet. Continue reading “Balancing a High Sodium Diet” >

Stocking a Healthy Kitchen on a Budget

Quick and Dirty Tips for Eating Well and Feeling FabulousThis week’s podcast is for recent college graduates and others who are new to the business of food shopping, meal planning, and preparation. To be honest, even experienced householders often struggle with these tasks.  If you’ve ever unloaded 8 bags of groceries only to discover that you don’t have the makings for a single meal, you know what I mean—and these tips can help. Read or listen to it here.

3 Ways to Fight Childhood Obesity

Quick and Dirty Tips for Eating Well and Feeling FabulousToday, one in every 5 kids is obese and a great many more are overweight. Not only is this a cruddy way to spend your childhood, but overweight kids are highly likely to become overweight adults, battling both their weight and the associated health problems for a lifetime. In this week’s podcast, I outline three simple things you can do to  help your kids maintain a healthy weight. Read or listen to it here.

How Nutritious is 100% Fruit Juice? Not Very.

Q. What should I look for when buying fruit juice? For example the “100% pure and natural orange juice” says it contains 0% Vitamin C. How is that possible? Another one provides 100% Vitamin C but from the list of ingredients we see that Vitamin C is actually added.

A. The USDA considers a half cup of fruit juice equivalent to a serving of fruit but I have my doubts. Processed fruit juice–even 100% juice–is a distant second to fresh whole fruit in terms of its nutritional value. For one thing, fruit juice is a very concentrated source of sugar and calories. All the fiber, which slows the absorption of the sugars in whole fruit, has been removed.

Secondly, many (most?) of the naturally-occurring nutrients are lost during processing, pasteurization, and storage. As you found, manufacturers may compensate for this by adding nutrients back to the juice after the fact. You could get the same benefit from taking a vitamin C capsule.

See also: Juicing for Health and Nutrition

Juice and Diabetes Risk

Nutritionally, I’d rank processed fruit juice only slightly higher than soda and other sweetened beverages. In fact, a large study conducted in China found that people who drink two or more servings of juice a week are 25% more likely to develop Type 2 diabetes compared to those who rarely drink juice. This is consistent with another large 2008 study, which also found that increased juice consumption led to an increased risk of Type 2 diabetes–but that eating more whole fruit decreased diabetes risk.

My Advice?

Eat Fruit; Drink Water.  (Same for your kids!)

_____________

My newest book, Secrets for a Healthy Diet: What to Eat, What to Avoid, and What to Stop Worrying About is my essential guide to all the food choices you make every day.  Read a sample chapter here.